Markov or Sourray

Frank the Critic · Member

Markov or Sourray

Caper_hab_fan · Veteran Member

You really can't compare the two. Markov is just a solid D man, leader in ice time, great on the powerplay, good skater and passer. Souray is a big physical D man, with a power shot, but not as smart Defensively. I say keep both....haha

plouf · Guru

Give me Markov any day. Souray is WAY more inconsistent and also has a history of injury. Souray's much more of a leader though, where Markov's quiet.

We have seen how the Habs consistently do poorly when Markov is out of the lineup.

Habs record with Markov in lineup:

28-16-8

Habs record without Markov in lineup:

3-10-1

For me, Markov's Team MVP this year, hands down.

-- Edited by plouf at 21:39, 2006-03-19

Key Lime · Guru

plouf wrote:

Give me Markov any day. Souray is WAY more inconsistent and also has a history of injury. Souray's much more of a leader though, where Markov's quiet. We have seen how the Habs consistently do poorly when Markov is out of the lineup. Habs record with Markov in lineup: 28-16-8 Habs record without Markov in lineup: 3-10-1 For me, Markov's Team MVP this year, hands down. -- Edited by plouf at 21:39, 2006-03-19

Sorry...no brainer for me...Markov

AB Habman · Guru

plouf wrote:

Give me Markov any day. Souray is WAY more inconsistent and also has a history of injury. Souray's much more of a leader though, where Markov's quiet. We have seen how the Habs consistently do poorly when Markov is out of the lineup. Habs record with Markov in lineup: 28-16-8 Habs record without Markov in lineup: 3-10-1 For me, Markov's Team MVP this year, hands down. -- Edited by plouf at 21:39, 2006-03-19

I actually agee with Plouf! Markov has been solid this season. He may have the nod for MVP over Huet.

plouf · Guru

Wow....

AB, I think we actually agreed about something once before.

But this calls for a celebration!

davidb · Guru

I dont now whos better, but we can agree we need them both playing for the playoffs

Habtastic · Guru

Markov is in my top 3 fav players in the league and has been for a few seasons, so there is no question for me, it's Marky-boy!

Habtastic

Nil d · Guru

It's definitely Markov for me too. Souray is probably a better leader in terms of the soft skills, but Markov has it all over him on the ice. We need him back on the point on the PP ASAP.

Plouf's stats say it all.

Without a doubt, Montreal's MVP this year.

24 Rings · Guru

I like everything about Souray, except his defensive play. I'll go with Markov as well - he just gets it done on both ends of the ice.

habgirl · Guru

Keep 'em both. I like Shelly's physical presence, hard shot and leadership. But, Markov gets the job done effectively on both ends of the ice.

If I HAD to choose, I'd keep Markov. Kovy, Koivu and Abby would all be in the doghouse...

Good thing I'm not GM, I guess.