I found this list on a site, thought it was pretty decent conversation starter.

Habtastic


List of overpaid players in the NHL
Anaheim: Jean-Sebastien Giguere - 3.99 million$

Atlanta: Bobby Holik - 4.25 million$

Boston: Zdeno Chara - 7.5 miliion$
Marc Savard - 5 million$
Glen Murray - 4.15 milion$
Alexei Zhamnov - 4.1 million$
Paul Mara(in my opinion) - 3 million$

Buffalo: Jaroslav Spacek - 3.225 million$
Daniel Briere - 5 million$

Calgary: Nobody maybe Tanguay or Hamrlik but i don't think so.

Carolina: Brind'Amour - 4 million$

Chicago: Martin Havlat - 6 million$
Adrian Aucoin - 4 million$

Colorado: Joe Sakic - 5.75 million$ seriously come on guys
Jose Theodore - 5.5 million$
Patrice Brisebois - 3 million$

Columbus: Sergei Fedorov - 6.08 million$
Adam Foote - 4.6 million$

Dallas: Marty Turco - 6 million$

Detroit: Robert Lang - 3.8 million$

Edmonton: Dwayne Roloson - 4 million$

Florida: Nobody

Los Angeles: Rob Blake - 6 million$
Mattias Norstrom - 4.25 million$

Minnesota: Kim Johnsson - 4.05 million$

Montreal: Saku Koivu - 4.75 million$

Nashville: Jason Arnott - 4.5 million$

New Jersey: Brian Rafalski - 4.2 million$

NY Islanders: Alexei Yashin - 7.6 million$

NY Rangers: Nobody

Philadelphia: Nobody

Phoenix: Ed Jovanovski - 7 million$ too much for an injured player

Pittsburgh: Nobody

Ottawa: Nobody

San Jose: Evgeni Nabokov - 5 million$

Saint Louis: Jay Mckee - 4 million$
Doug Weight - 3. 75 million$

Tampa Bay: Brad Richards - 7.8 million$
Vincent Lecavalier - 7.167 million$
Martin St.Louis - 6 million$
Filip Kuba - 3 million$

Toronto: Bryan McCabe - 5 million$
Pavel Kubina - 5 million$

Vancouver: Willie Mitchell - 3.5 million$

Washington: Brian Pothier - 2.5 million