Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Final Roster?


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 934
Date:
Final Roster?
Permalink Closed


Since I got back from Germany I've been going over the Habs line up over and over. How has the line up improved, simply concerning the player changes? I'm not speaking of rookies coming up etc....Let's simply argue the 3 players we don't have anymore vs. the 2 players that were picked up.


We don't have Zednik, Bulis, and Sundstrom but we added Johnson and Samsanov. Someone please tell me where the improvement lies.


I have faith that the team may be better than last season due to team chemistry and stable goaltending BUT last season there was so much talk about the Habs making a run for the cup in 2 seasons that I question if that is even realistic anymore. Was it ever realistic?


Aren't we more like 3-4 years away? Even 3-4 years from now, I don't see Kovalev, Koivu, or even Huet being of any value or even in Habs uni anymore. So this means that we need players to start showing major signs of replacing such players...


I may have just rambled on and on in this post but bare with me, I was hockey-starved for 6 weeks.


 



__________________
Stop Winging It... LM


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 289
Date:
Permalink Closed

get rid of Bonk for a 2nd round pick, trade Abby for a decent d-man or package the 2 for a d-man.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
Permalink Closed

He has 2 more years in his contract

__________________
GOHABSBOARD 2006 Hockey Playoff Pool Champion!!


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 289
Date:
Permalink Closed

anyone know when Crosby will be a unrestricted free agent?? he is a Habs fan, I can see him in a Habs uniform down the road

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3191
Date:
Permalink Closed


Key Lime wrote:


Since I got back from Germany I've been going over the Habs line up over and over. How has the line up improved, simply concerning the player changes? I'm not speaking of rookies coming up etc....Let's simply argue the 3 players we don't have anymore vs. the 2 players that were picked up. We don't have Zednik, Bulis, and Sundstrom but we added Johnson and Samsanov. Someone please tell me where the improvement lies. I have faith that the team may be better than last season due to team chemistry and stable goaltending BUT last season there was so much talk about the Habs making a run for the cup in 2 seasons that I question if that is even realistic anymore. Was it ever realistic? Aren't we more like 3-4 years away? Even 3-4 years from now, I don't see Kovalev, Koivu, or even Huet being of any value or even in Habs uni anymore. So this means that we need players to start showing major signs of replacing such players... I may have just rambled on and on in this post but bare with me, I was hockey-starved for 6 weeks.  


I am just happy that someone else on this board is not punch drunk with feelings that we are so much improved we are going to be contending for a cup this year.



__________________
________________ I'm as confused as a starving baby in a topless bar!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
Permalink Closed


Diehardhabsfan wrote:

anyone know when Crosby will be a unrestricted free agent?? he is a Habs fan, I can see him in a Habs uniform down the road



see above post, dunno why this happens lol

__________________
GOHABSBOARD 2006 Hockey Playoff Pool Champion!!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3452
Date:
Permalink Closed

Key Lime wrote:


We don't have Zednik, Bulis, and Sundstrom but we added Johnson and Samsanov. Someone please tell me where the improvement lies.


Johnson is as good as or better than Bulis, losing Sundstrom, who is a negative, is a plus, and Samsonov is much better than Zednik.  So isn't that good, if not great, improvement?



 



__________________
Time flies like an arrow. Fruit flies like a banana.


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 639
Date:
Permalink Closed

limer if you cant see where weve improved ill try to enlighten you , bulis had a career year last year at 40 points , johnson replaces him and has been in the league for 9years and has had over 40 pts 6 times , plus is as good defensively and as fast .and wont bitch about bein on the 3rd line . big plus for us . sammy replaces zednik , zeds has been in a tailspin since he was smacked by mclaren . he had 3o pts last year and his tops was 50 , his top asst were 24, sammy is as fast as shifty (more so)
and has put up 53 point last year , his high is 75 and has had 2 40+ assist seasons , he can pass the puck unlike zeds. thats just the additions we've made , the kids should be better , noone could be as bad as theo last year so if huet can stay steady or even if he slps abit were still ahead , so overall we have improved quite abit .


barry i dont feel we are cup contenders yet but we improved over last year , and if any fans of carolina or edmonton had them pegged as cup contenders last year then they were drunk as you say , the truth is we dont know who will compete for the cup could be us could be boston or to. were we cup contenders in 93 , i believe we finishe 3rd in our division that year , but the stars alined for us as the did for carolina and edmonton did this year and voila' your raising the cup . now im not gonna hold my breath but if its ok with you ill keep a little hope .

-- Edited by macneil at 23:07, 2006-07-25

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1635
Date:
Permalink Closed

I'm expecting big improvements with our defense and overall team mentality, which clearly made progress from two years ago.

But I agree, I'm still not sold on our "improvements" at forward (Samsonov has yet to prove himself as a consistent top-line guy in my opinion). The key is that guys like Perezhogin should be ready to make it or bust, let's hope for a big year. And it's true that we are looking like a more stable team with an identity than two years ago. But .... I'm still not sold. And I haven't liked our drafting for two seasons in a row.

One good thing - our playoff performance showed potential. We really only had one bad game, (hey in 93 we had a few) and we had a lot of games where we fought tooth and nail for every inch of ice against the eventual cup winners. There's hope and a positive mentality.



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3452
Date:
Permalink Closed

Plouf, it's good to see you posting again, in your usual balanced manner. 


Where had you been lately?




__________________
Time flies like an arrow. Fruit flies like a banana.


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2344
Date:
Permalink Closed


Key Lime wrote:


Since I got back from Germany I've been going over the Habs line up over and over. How has the line up improved, simply concerning the player changes? I'm not speaking of rookies coming up etc....Let's simply argue the 3 players we don't have anymore vs. the 2 players that were picked up. We don't have Zednik, Bulis, and Sundstrom but we added Johnson and Samsanov. Someone please tell me where the improvement lies. I have faith that the team may be better than last season due to team chemistry and stable goaltending BUT last season there was so much talk about the Habs making a run for the cup in 2 seasons that I question if that is even realistic anymore. Was it ever realistic? Aren't we more like 3-4 years away? Even 3-4 years from now, I don't see Kovalev, Koivu, or even Huet being of any value or even in Habs uni anymore. So this means that we need players to start showing major signs of replacing such players... I may have just rambled on and on in this post but bare with me, I was hockey-starved for 6 weeks.  


Key Lime....we're a better regular season team than last season because of the Theo crap but without another significant move at deadline, we're not going deep in the playoffs. Sammy will not forecheck hard like a Zed type player did against Canes. Our skill players need to get dirty and dig the pucks out or Kovy and Sammy will have no puck possession. At this point I don't like that line even if Saks is in the middle. We need a big hard nosed centerman in between them or split them up. With this lineup Carb will have to get lucky with line combos in the playoffs.


See Key Lime....I'm being positive...we'll make the playoffs!



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3191
Date:
Permalink Closed

yes we have improved..no question. But even Gainey will admit that he had hoped for two things going into this year..an improvement at Center and a stud dman. We have neither and they are our 2 biggest holes. But there is no question Gainey tried to fill those holes and just could not. Gainey was on the team 990 yesterday and was asked for his opinion on Ribero. He replied "Well certainly Mike has the skills but he is a gamble for us this year". That comment indicates that Gainey is not happy or content with what we have up the middle. I think he will give Ribs a short leash and continue working on filling the hole.

__________________
________________ I'm as confused as a starving baby in a topless bar!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 639
Date:
Permalink Closed

i heard that too barry , it was either a slip of the toungue or a well place jab to get him motivated . you never know with b.g. there is no doubt we could improve in those areas but given that we couldn't/ didnt , we will have to press on with what we have and maybe pickup someone later through a trade.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3191
Date:
Permalink Closed

macneil wrote:


i heard that too barry , it was either a slip of the toungue or a well place jab to get him motivated . you never know with b.g. there is no doubt we could improve in those areas but given that we couldn't/ didnt , we will have to press on with what we have and maybe pickup someone later through a trade.

Mac- Bob knows better than any of us the holes that need filled. I am convinced he did the best he could with what he had and will continue to work towards that end. In the meantime, I am sure excited to see Samsonov and Kovy on the same line (and hoipefully that will fire up Kovy too!) Can we start the season tomorrow?

__________________
________________ I'm as confused as a starving baby in a topless bar!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 639
Date:
Permalink Closed

wish we could , and if ribs cant cut it with those linemates he goes elsewhere and we give pleks or brabovski a shot , if we cant trade for a better option.


what do you think of switching ribs and saks , he has more speed than ribs , better defensivly , and ribs could work with ryder and higgs because they are slower , and more grinding scorers .

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
Permalink Closed


barry33 wrote:



I am just happy that someone else on this board is not punch drunk with feelings that we are so much improved we are going to be contending for a cup this year.




Its not being punch drunk, its being a fan, and believing in your team. I can't wait till the habs do good this year and so many of you guys shut up and jump back onto the wagon

__________________
GOHABSBOARD 2006 Hockey Playoff Pool Champion!!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1635
Date:
Permalink Closed

Hey, I believe.

But at the same time I know we didn't get it done at the centre position. ALL FOUR of our centres are gambles, not just Ribs. I really can't Iin a million years) see us winning the cup without some changes. Sorry. But Edmonton nearly pulled it off last year with a couple of changes so you never know....

The best thing we have going for us (I think) is that the team mentality will be better. We will be more focused and deep at the goaltender position.

I'm still saying 07-08, just like I said last year, and just like Muller has been saying all along.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
Permalink Closed

well, what gets me is that why do so many people here hate on the habs (and don't give me any 'being realistic' crap). If you don't like the way things are going, cheer for a favorite then.

__________________
GOHABSBOARD 2006 Hockey Playoff Pool Champion!!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3191
Date:
Permalink Closed

Jay1982 wrote:


well, what gets me is that why do so many people here hate on the habs (and don't give me any 'being realistic' crap). If you don't like the way things are going, cheer for a favorite then.


So jay are you saying that all posts on this site should be positive, blind to the obvious and RA RA Habs?!?? How boring would THAT BE? I am the first to admit that at times I can get on a negative run on posts on here and I try to correct that. But I am not going tgo come onto this site and pretend that the habs have addressed all their issues and will be suddenly contending for a cup this year. Why is it that it needs to be black and white with some people on here? YOu say something semi-negaitive about the Captain and all of a sudden you hate Koivu and have a personaly agenda. YOu point out defficiencies in the team and you are a "habs hater" and should go cheer for your favorite team.


I do not agree with everyones opinions here but I respect their right to express it in a sensible manner, Plouf simply pointed out that he feels it will be at least 07-08 before everything gels but that he sees definite improvement now. What is wrong with THAT?!???



__________________
________________ I'm as confused as a starving baby in a topless bar!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1746
Date:
Permalink Closed

Nothing wrong with being realistic Barry.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
Permalink Closed

I'm not attacking anyone because they make a few gray-area posts. I respect a person's right to post what they want (which is what I'm doing right now). What rattles me is all the negativity, some people post positive things. And its not like you sometimes post a negative comment. Its the people who ONLY post negative comments, or very little positive. I agree, the habs do have problems to address. But who doesn't?!!. Name me one team that has one the cup in the last 25 years that hasn't had some problem or weak area!

You mentioned that if someone makes a comment towards saku, they are automatically a hater. What about people who stand up for koivu who then get called various names as well?? Even in a few cases suggesting that a particular person has a homoerotic facination with our #11????

I'm not blind Barry. I know where the habs are weak in a few areas, but that doesn't automatically make the habs a flop. If you have already written off the habs till 2009 or whatever year everyone thinks the habs will win the cup, why are you guys following the team this upcoming season? Why waste your time?

Anything can happen in sports, and to constantly make negative posts (not just you Barry) is gettinga bit OLD!!

Not blind...but a believer to the end!

__________________
GOHABSBOARD 2006 Hockey Playoff Pool Champion!!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3191
Date:
Permalink Closed

Jay1982 wrote:


I'm not attacking anyone because they make a few gray-area posts. I respect a person's right to post what they want (which is what I'm doing right now). What rattles me is all the negativity, some people post positive things. And its not like you sometimes post a negative comment. Its the people who ONLY post negative comments, or very little positive. I agree, the habs do have problems to address. But who doesn't?!!. Name me one team that has one the cup in the last 25 years that hasn't had some problem or weak area! You mentioned that if someone makes a comment towards saku, they are automatically a hater. What about people who stand up for koivu who then get called various names as well?? Even in a few cases suggesting that a particular person has a homoerotic facination with our #11???? I'm not blind Barry. I know where the habs are weak in a few areas, but that doesn't automatically make the habs a flop. If you have already written off the habs till 2009 or whatever year everyone thinks the habs will win the cup, why are you guys following the team this upcoming season? Why waste your time? Anything can happen in sports, and to constantly make negative posts (not just you Barry) is gettinga bit OLD!! Not blind...but a believer to the end!

Hey its all good buddy. I have never been off the bandwagon. I just view things up here a bit differently than some others lol. Make no mistake. I LOVE this team. I blead red white and bleu. I think we ar egonna have an awesome year and we will be competitiive. And I still think BG will find us a center..then watch out!

__________________
________________ I'm as confused as a starving baby in a topless bar!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1746
Date:
Permalink Closed

Jay1982 wrote:


I'm not attacking anyone because they make a few gray-area posts. I respect a person's right to post what they want (which is what I'm doing right now). What rattles me is all the negativity, some people post positive things. And its not like you sometimes post a negative comment. Its the people who ONLY post negative comments, or very little positive. I agree, the habs do have problems to address. But who doesn't?!!. Name me one team that has one the cup in the last 25 years that hasn't had some problem or weak area! You mentioned that if someone makes a comment towards saku, they are automatically a hater. What about people who stand up for koivu who then get called various names as well?? Even in a few cases suggesting that a particular person has a homoerotic facination with our #11???? I'm not blind Barry. I know where the habs are weak in a few areas, but that doesn't automatically make the habs a flop. If you have already written off the habs till 2009 or whatever year everyone thinks the habs will win the cup, why are you guys following the team this upcoming season? Why waste your time? Anything can happen in sports, and to constantly make negative posts (not just you Barry) is gettinga bit OLD!! Not blind...but a believer to the end!

Great post Jay. Now there's a true Habs fan.

__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 289
Date:
Permalink Closed

Jay1982 wrote:


I'm not attacking anyone because they make a few gray-area posts. I respect a person's right to post what they want (which is what I'm doing right now). What rattles me is all the negativity, some people post positive things. And its not like you sometimes post a negative comment. Its the people who ONLY post negative comments, or very little positive. I agree, the habs do have problems to address. But who doesn't?!!. Name me one team that has one the cup in the last 25 years that hasn't had some problem or weak area! You mentioned that if someone makes a comment towards saku, they are automatically a hater. What about people who stand up for koivu who then get called various names as well?? Even in a few cases suggesting that a particular person has a homoerotic facination with our #11???? I'm not blind Barry. I know where the habs are weak in a few areas, but that doesn't automatically make the habs a flop. If you have already written off the habs till 2009 or whatever year everyone thinks the habs will win the cup, why are you guys following the team this upcoming season? Why waste your time? Anything can happen in sports, and to constantly make negative posts (not just you Barry) is gettinga bit OLD!! Not blind...but a believer to the end!

Awesome post Jay!!

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1350
Date:
Permalink Closed

Scarey thought. Saku on the same line as Samsonov. Probably could call it the todler line Especially if Bouillon is on defense while they are on! I SURE hope there is enough SPEED  to put up with the muscle those guys are going to have to endure!

__________________
At just 18, i've got the girl who has said the 6 words i've wanted to hear my whole life!! " My Dad Owns A Liquor Store"


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1081
Date:
Permalink Closed

Johab! What is with all the cynicism dude? I always thought of you as a positive guy, but someone put a burr in your saddle this week. :)

Hope all is well,

Habtastic

P.S. The difference between many small, speedy guys, is those two have a LOT of moxy!

__________________
http://habtastic.typepad.com/


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 289
Date:
Permalink Closed

working at dirty donalds will do that to a man

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
Permalink Closed

Thanks guys!!

__________________
GOHABSBOARD 2006 Hockey Playoff Pool Champion!!


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1635
Date:
Permalink Closed

All right, realism or optimism or whatever aside. We have this roster, at least for now. So what would be your system for a team like this?
Clearly we have some skilled players, and a good amount of speed up front. We also have a fairly physical defense corps if Komisarek keeps improving, and probably better team unity than in the past.

I'm hoping hoping hoping that we go with a 2-man forecheck, in almost all situations. I like the way Julien had the guys cycling the puck early last year, and I think we have the players to make it happen.

On our power play we can't have our little centres going to the net. It was ridiculous last year with Koivu trying to get in there, and Ribeiro being the guy looking for passes from Kovalev in the crease. I really think we need to use some of our bigger forwards up front on the power play. What about Bonk? I know the guy seems cursed, but he has always shown himself to be a real pest in front of the net, on offense and defense. Why not try him on the power play and let Koivu play from the half-boards where he belongs, with Kovalev looking to get behind the net or in the slot as needed?

Biggest worry is at the point. But I think Souray should be on the #1 unit no matter what, even with his slow release, because we need to have that threat, with Markov looking to set people up or take wrist shots.

I'd like to see us roll four lines, with Kovalev seeing some extra shifts on other lines. As everyone has pointed out, Koivu is best when he doesn't have to play all the time, and we have a lot of young guys who aren't quite top-2 liners but need the playing time to get in synch (PErezhogin, Plekanec, Kostsitsyn, etc...)...

And so Koivu shouldn't be on the PK at all, except in key situations (no matter what anyone says about Bonk, Koivu was easily our best faceoff guy last year, for example). Let's use Plekanec, Higgins, Begin, Bonk as the PK guys. Put Bonk on the 4th line and give him lots of special teams time (that's where he's best by far), but give the 4th line more than 5 minutes a game.

More ideas? Love to hear 'em.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1081
Date:
Permalink Closed

Sounds about right to me, Plouf. 2-man forecheck is my fav.

Habtastic

__________________
http://habtastic.typepad.com/
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard